Wednesday, November 26, 2014

Ministry Amid Civil Marriages and Cohabitation

One of the many eye-catching paragraphs of the mid-term report from the Extraordinary Synod on the Family reads as follows (under the heading “Positive Aspects of Civil Unions and Cohabitation”):

“A new sensitivity in today’s pastoral consists in grasping the positive reality of civil weddings and, having pointed out our differences, of cohabitation. It is necessary that in the ecclesial proposal, while clearly presenting the ideal, we also indicate the constructive elements in those situations that do not yet or no longer correspond to that ideal.”

This does not mean we should recognize civil marriages and/or cohabitation as licit expressions of life in the Body of Christ; it means we should identify good elements that exist in these and use them as a foundation to lead people to the fullness of what God wants for them. Recall the principle established by the Synod that we discussed in my previous post:

“Discerning and affirming values present in irregular situations means we find the good in a situation and build upon it, rather than condemning the situation outright. Instead of using an approach that says “You’re wrong, you’d better change your lifestyle or you’re going to hell” (which immediately builds walls of defensiveness and alienation and accomplishes nothing), we use an approach that begins with “You’ve got some good things going for you, I can see where God has been working in your life,” which builds the trust and openness that is the foundation for a respectful examination of other things that need to change.”

This requires the doors to the Church be open to people in irregular situations, offering a place of welcome where they will be lovingly encouraged to grow. An open door does not mean validation of irregular lifestyles, nor does it necessarily mean full participation in the sacraments; it means validation of the person as a child of God in need of a nurturing place to grow, and perhaps inclusion in the sacraments where appropriate.

This section of the report referenced Evangelii Gaudium, an apostolic exhortation given by Pope Francis in 2013. Paragraph 47 of that document states (emphasis added):

“Everyone can share in some way in the life of the Church; everyone can be part of the community, nor should the doors of the sacraments be closed for simply any reason.”

“Simply any reason” does not refer to the canonical requirements for admission to the sacraments, for they are soundly established. It refers to arbitrary impediments placed at the discretion of pastors which are counter-productive to ministry. Speaking of the Eucharist in particular, Pope Francis wrote that it “is not a prize for the perfect but a powerful medicine and nourishment for the weak…. Frequently we act as arbiters of grace rather than its facilitators. But the Church is not a tollhouse; it is the house of the Father, where there is a place for everyone, with all their problems.”

Guided by this principle, the report said of civil marriages and cohabitation:


“All these situations have to be dealt with in a constructive manner, seeking to transform them into opportunities to walk towards the fullness of marriage and the family in light of the Gospel. They need to be welcomed and accompanied with patience and delicacy, as subjects for the evangelization of the family.”

Principles of Ministry to People in Irregular Situations

We’ll soon turn our attention to another portion of the midterm report from the Extraordinary Synod on the Family that raised eyebrows: how it spoke of “positive aspects of civil unions and cohabitation.” But first we need to understand three foundational principles of ministry that were spelled out in this document:

1. We must keep our gaze on Jesus and imitate his gaze.
2. We must operate from the “law of gradualness,” not “gradualness of the law.”
3. We must discern and affirm the values present in wounded families and irregular situations, then work from there.

Let’s briefly visit each of these principles.

1. With regards to imitating Jesus, Pope Francis says we must practice the “’art of accompaniment,’ which teaches us to remove our sandals before the sacred ground of the other.” This means we recognize the dignity of every human being as a child of God made in his image and likeness and treat them accordingly, no matter their situation.

2. The “law of gradualness” recognizes that nobody goes from their current state of imperfection to the fullness of the divine image in one leap. Everyone grows in stages--some grow more quickly than others, some may be able to skip some steps while others move one at a time, some fall back a step after taking two forward, etc. The law of gradualness calls for patience, and trust in the varied ways God works in people’s lives.

This is not to be confused with “gradualness of the law,” the fallacy that the law does not apply to people who have not yet reach the stage where they can follow it, that the law should be adapted according to each individual’s ability to follow it.

3. Discerning and affirming values present in irregular situations means we find the good in a situation and build upon it, rather than condemning the situation outright. Instead of using an approach that says “You’re wrong, you’d better change your lifestyle or you’re going to hell” (which immediately builds walls of defensiveness and alienation and accomplishes nothing), we use an approach that begins with “You’ve got some good things going for you, I can see where God has been working in your life,” which builds the trust and openness that is the foundation for a respectful examination of other things that need to change.

Such an approach is reminiscent of the words of St. John XXIII in his opening address at the Second Vatican Council:

“The Church has always opposed these errors, and often condemned them with the utmost severity. Today, however, Christ’s Bride prefers the balm of mercy to the arm of severity. She believes that present needs are best served by explaining more fully the purport of her doctrines, rather than by publishing condemnations.”


With those principles established, we’ll examine some of the “irregular situations” the Synod discussed in my next post.

The Barilla Case: Are We Losing Our Noodles?

I’d like to comment on a disturbing story that appeared in the Washington Post on November 19.

The story involves Barilla, the world’s largest pasta manufacturer, and, as journalist Sandhya Somashekhar wrote, “how toxic it has become for a company to be viewed as unfriendly toward gays.”

Key words: “viewed as.”

In September 2013 Barilla’s chairman, Guido Barilla, told an Italian radio host, “I would never do [a commercial] with a homosexual couple, not for lack of respect, but because we don’t agree with them.” He continued: “If [gays] don’t like it, they can go eat another brand.”

That they did. Mr. Barilla’s comments prompted boycotts of his company around the globe, including the United States, which comprises 30% of Barilla’s market.  Harvard University removed their products from its cafeterias, gay rights groups promoted other brands of pasta, and Barilla’s competitors “seized on the opportunity to present themselves as more forward-thinking.”

Then came this disheartening line: “Guido Barilla issued multiple video apologies in the wake of the scandal.”

What did he say that would require an apology, and where was the scandal?

Re-read Mr. Barilla’s comment, with emphasis added: “I would not do [a commercial] with a homosexual couple, not for lack of respect, but because we don’t agree with them.”


Since when in civilized society does one need to apologize for respectfully disagreeing with someone else? How in civilized society does respectful disagreement come to be viewed as a scandal?

Monday, November 24, 2014

Theology of the Body in Bite-Size Pieces, Part Twelve

We’ve established that male and female were created in God’s image, that as such they were created to yearn for each other and to be joined as one body in covenantal union, an icon of the inner life of the Holy Trinity, open to procreation of new life. Sacramental marriage reflects Jesus’ marriage with his bride, the Church, to whom he gives his body in love.

In his book Theology of the Body for Beginners Christopher West writes the following:

“Christ’s love seems distinguishable by four particular qualities. First, Christ gives his body freely (“No one takes my life from me, I lay it down of my own accord,” Jn 10:18). Second, he gives his body totally--without reservation, condition, or selfish calculation (“He loved them to the last,” Jn 13:1). Third, he gives his body faithfully (“I am with you always,” Mt 28:20). And fourth, he gives his body fruitfully (“I came that they may have life,” Jn 10:10). If men and women are to avoid the pitfalls of counterfeit love, and live their vocation to its full, their union must express the same free, total, faithful, fruitful love that Christ expresses.

“Ultimately all questions of sexual morality come down to one very simple question: Does this act truly image God’s free, total, faithful, fruitful love or does it not?”

Contraception does not image God’s free, total, faithful, fruitful love. It robs the sacred union of husband and wife of its inherent divine image.

There is nothing immoral about purposely avoiding pregnancy for legitimate reasons. (“We don’t want to be bothered with children” is not a legitimate reason. Serious financial difficulties, the emotional demands of other children, health concerns, these are legitimate reasons.) But using contraception is never morally licit. God built into the body his plan for married couples to conceive children as well as to avoid conception; faithfulness to the nuptial meaning of the body images and glorifies God, contraception, which is not faithful to this meaning, does not.

Many people ask “What’s the difference, really, between contraception and natural family planning? They both achieve the same end. The Church teaches that every sexual union of husband and wife must be open to procreation--but when a couple uses natural family planning they are also trying to avoid pregnancy, they’re having sex while not being open to procreation either! Isn’t this a hypocritical stance?”


There is a fundamental difference between contraception and natural family planning, and this difference is what we’ll explore next in this series.

Wednesday, November 19, 2014

Jesus and "Irregular Situations"

The Church has to [minister to people in irregular family situations] with the tenderness of a mother and the clarity of a teacher (cf. Eph 4,15), in fidelity to the merciful kenosi of Christ. The truth is incarnated in human fragility not to condemn it, but to cure it.

This passage from the midterm report of the Extraordinary Synod of Bishops on the Family didn’t receive much press, but it deserves our careful attention. In my last post I quoted Pope Francis’ reprimands to the extremes of both sides: those who have the clarity of a teacher but not the tenderness of a mother (what he deemed “so-called ‘traditionalists’”), and those with the tenderness of a mother but not the clarity of a teacher (what he deemed “so-called ‘progressives and liberals’”). Jesus displayed both qualities in abundance; two examples from the Gospel of John highlight Jesus’ approach to those in “irregular family situations.”

In John 8:4 an angry mob brings a woman to Jesus and says: “Teacher, this woman was caught in the very act of committing adultery.”(It’s interesting that the question “Who caught her in the very act? Who was watching?” is not asked!) They are eager to stone her, and ask Jesus for his opinion, hoping to trap him. We know Jesus’ famous response: “Let the one among you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone at her.” (John 8:7) After the crowd leaves we read this exchange between Jesus and the woman:

“Woman, where are they? Has no one condemned you?”
She replied, “No one, sir.”
Then Jesus said, “Neither do I condemn you. Go, and from now on do not sin any more.”
(John 8:10-11)

What is often overlooked by those with the tenderness of a mother but not the clarity of a teacher is that twice in this story Jesus agrees with the mob that this woman has sinned. (“Let the one among you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone at her” implies that she has indeed sinned. Jesus is saying “Yes, you’re right, she has sinned--but so have all of you!”) When Jesus says to the woman “Go, and from now on do not sin anymore” it is clear he does not condone her irregular situation, for he considers it sin. Rather, he orders her to stop living the way she has been. This order is not one of condemnation; it expresses love for this woman who has fallen short of how God intends for her to live, and Jesus’ desire that she leave her sinful lifestyle behind.

Another example is Jesus’ meeting with the Samaritan woman at the well in John 4. She comes to the well at noon, the hottest hour of the day and the most uncomfortable time to perform that task, because she expects no one to be there. She is an outcast in her town, and she does not want to face her tormentors.

But it is there, in the midst of her shame and alienation, that she encounters Jesus. He seeks her out in her place of loneliness, where she never expected to meet anyone.

Like the adulterous woman in John 8, this woman is in an “irregular situation,” having had five husbands and now living with a man who is not her husband. Jesus does not condone this, he does not tell her it is okay to be living like this. Rather, he points out the irregularity in her lifestyle with such love and compassion that it touches her in a way no preaching ever could.

Read that story carefully. Prior to Jesus’ showing that he knows all about her situation, the woman’s end of the conversation remains on a superficial, earthly plane. Once Jesus touches the depths of her heart, revealing not what is good and holy but exposing what is weak, she is suddenly able to break through and can now discuss spiritual things.

This is what happens to all of us when we can acknowledge our weakness to Jesus—walls come down, true healing can take place, and the relationship can now be deepened. This is how we must conduct ourselves as members of the Body of Christ with people in such delicate situations.

The preparatory document for the Synod, based on responses to a survey of the world’s episcopal conferences, made this profound point:

Some episcopal conferences argue that the reason for much resistance to the Church’s teaching on moral issues related to the family is a want of an authentic Christian experience, namely, an encounter with Christ on a personal and communal level, for which no doctrinal presentation, no matter how accurate, can substitute. In this regard, some responses point to the insufficiency of pastoral activity which is concerned only with dispensing the sacraments without a truly engaging Christian experience.

In other words, we can preach doctrine until we’re blue in the face, but unless someone’s heart has been touched by a true encounter with Christ, even the best doctrinal presentation won’t take root. Touching hearts is a key first step of evangelization, without which none of the other steps can follow.


In subsequent posts we’ll continue to explore the important points made by the Extraordinary Synod on the Family.

Tuesday, November 18, 2014

Theology of the Body in Bite-Size Pieces, Part Eleven

To the woman he said: “I will intensify the pangs of your childbearing; in pain shall you bring forth children, yet your urge shall be for your husband, and he shall be your master.” (Genesis 3:14-16)

We reflected on the pangs of childbearing in Part Ten. Let’s now focus on the rest of this passage: “…yet your urge shall be for your husband, and he shall be your master.”

The marriage of husband and wife is an image of God’s covenant with his people, as illustrated in many Scripture passages. Specifically, God made flesh--Jesus Christ--is the bridegroom, the Church is his bride. (See Ephesians 5:31-32, Revelation 19:7).

The bride’s urge to be one flesh with her husband images the Church’s urge to be one flesh with Jesus Christ. This union takes place in Holy Communion, when the bridegroom’s flesh and blood mixes with the bride’s and they become one--that’s where the marriage is consummated. We begin to participate in the nuptial union of the Lamb and his bride spoken of in Revelation 19:7 every time we receive Holy Communion.

But what about the husband being the “master” of the wife? Remember that the New Testament completes the Old Testament, they are a unity. Reading the quote from Ephesians we mentioned in its broader context will shed some light on this verse from Genesis. Speaking to married couples, St. Paul writes this in Ephesians 5:21-32:


What does it mean for a wife to be subordinate to her husband as the Church is subordinate to Christ? Reflect on the relationship between Christ and his Church. Jesus said he came not to be served, but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many. (Matthew 20:28) Jesus made the ultimate sacrifice for his bride, so that she may have life. In other words the master does not lord his authority (Matthew 20:25-26), but serves. (“Whoever wishes to be great among you shall be your servant.” Matthew 20:26. “You call me teacher and master, and rightly so, for indeed I am. If I, therefore, the master and teacher, have washed your feet, you ought to wash one another’s feet.” John 13:13-14)


This is the kind of “master” Adam is to be for Eve, the kind that Jesus will be for his bride. This is what all married couples are called to be: Be subordinate to one another out of reverence for Christ.

Monday, November 17, 2014

Theology of the Body in Bite-Size Pieces, Part Ten

Then the Lord God said to the serpent: “Because you have done this, you shall be banned from all the animals and from all the wild creatures; on your belly shall you crawl, and dirt shall you eat all the days of your life. I will put enmity between you and the woman, and between your offspring and hers; he will strike at your head, while you strike at his heel.”

To the woman he said: “I will intensify the pangs of your childbearing; in pain shall you bring forth children, yet your urge shall be for your husband, and he shall be your master.” (Genesis 3:14-16)

There is a fascinating connection between the consequences God announced to the serpent and those he proclaimed to the woman. We will spend two parts of this series reflecting upon them.

To the serpent God declares that from this point on there will be enmity between the serpent and the woman, and more significantly, between their offspring. There are certain consequences mere creatures are powerless to reverse, and incurring debt to God for spoiling his creation is one. This is a debt that will be inherited by future generations, for creatures simply cannot repay it.

So yes, there will always be trouble between the two--but there is more.

The offspring of the serpent will strike at the heel of the woman’s offspring, which can cause problems but no permanent damage. An offspring of the woman, however, will strike at the head of the serpent, killing it. In this beautiful verse, in response to humanity’s sin, God promises a savior who will ultimately conquer evil and pay the debt humanity cannot pay. Yes, there are consequences to sin, and grave consequences for those who will not repent. But God loves humanity, the ones he created in his image, too much to leave us completely to our own devices.

In other words, while humans would now experience sexuality--created to be an icon of the inner life of the Holy Trinity--with a clouded vision not always able to see its true meaning (signified by the covering of their nakedness), sexuality would be redeemed by the promised savior, who would restore it to its rightful beauty.

The serpent striking at the heel is an image suggestive of the crucifixion. (There is evidence to suggest that in crucifixion nails were driven through the heel bones rather than the center of the feet.) The pains of childbirth are a powerful image of the same. Think about it: when a woman gives birth she suffers often excruciating pain so that another may have life. Life-sustaining fluids issue forth from her body, as did from Jesus’ body on the cross. The placenta--what nourished the child while in the womb--is discarded, a sign that the child is emerging from one kind of life to a totally different one, a life that calls for a different kind of food. (See Part Eight of this series for a reflection on the connection between earthly food and the Eucharist.)

And it all comes about through a woman suffering not so she may gain anything for herself, but in complete sacrifice for another.

So why does her husband become her master? We’ll reflect upon that in Part Eleven.