Saturday, November 15, 2014

Celibacy and the Nuptial Meaning of the Body

At the resurrection they neither marry nor are given in marriage. (Matthew 22:30)

Why not?

For the wedding day of the Lamb has come, and his bride has made herself ready. (Revelation 19:7)

Oh, that’s why!

Yes, marriage takes on a completely new form in Heaven; those who live celibate lives on earth are anticipating that marriage in a unique way.

Love is forever, but marriage is not--at least not the earthly variety. Like all sacraments, marriage is a visible (earthly) sign of an invisible (heavenly) reality. Like all signs, marriage points to something beyond itself, and we must ultimately leave the sign behind and go in the direction it points. What it points to is the Heavenly marriage of the Lamb (Jesus) with his Bride (all of us, the Church; see Ephesians 5:32).

Earthly, sacramental marriage is a living image of God’s covenant with his people, which will be consummated fully in the Heavenly Kingdom. There earthly, sacramental marriage will cease to exist, and the marriage of the Lamb with his Bride will take its place.

That is why at the resurrection they neither marry nor are given in marriage, for then we are all, as one body, married to the Lamb of God. That’s also why the marriage vows include the words “until death do we part.” Death is the end of earthly marriage so the Heavenly one can begin.

Yet marriage is not the only earthly experience that images the Heavenly marriage of the Lamb with his Bride. “Celibacy for the Kingdom of God” does the same in a different way. Just as Jesus did not take an earthly wife because the Church is his Bride, those who do not take an earthly spouse, when they join themselves in celibacy to Jesus Christ, have already begun on earth their betrothal to the one they will join in Heavenly marriage. As St. John Paul II stated: “Already in the conditions of the present temporal life [celibacy] seems to anticipate what man will share in, in the future resurrection.”

Thus celibacy is also a means to live the nuptial meaning of the body. Intimate union with another in an earthly body is sacrificed in anticipation of the greater good of eternal marriage in our glorified bodies with the Lamb of God.

So where do people with a homosexual orientation fit into this picture? They are clearly called to the celibate life, which means, in this context, they are actually invited to anticipate their eternal marriage with the Lamb while still on earth, as are some heterosexual people who are also called to celibacy.

Yes, there are trials in the life of a celibate person, as there are in the lives of married couples. Jesus also endured trials for his bride; this is a calling we all share.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church puts it this way:

[Homosexual] persons are called to fulfill God’s will in their lives and, if they are Christians, to unite to the sacrifice of the Lord’s Cross the difficulties they may encounter from their condition.


Homosexual persons are called to chastity. By the virtues of self-mastery that teach them inner freedom, at times by the support of disinterested friendship, by prayer and sacramental grace, they can and should gradually and resolutely approach Christian perfection. (2358-59)

Thursday, November 13, 2014

"Gay" or "Straight": Are We All In the Same Boat?

In my November 10 post we explored the real question raised by the Extraordinary Synod of Bishops about welcoming homosexuals in the Church. Today we’ll further reflect on this pastoral challenge in light of a fundamental question:

Given that the whole of human sexuality was wounded by original sin, how do the struggles of homosexuality compare with those of heterosexuality? Are there any similarities amid the obvious differences, and if so can we draw upon these similarities to minister to people with a predominantly same-sex attraction and help lead them to fulfillment through their sexual orientation?

Let’s begin by revisiting the theological foundation of human sexuality expressed by the first man’s reaction upon seeing the first woman (both of them naked) in the second creation story in Genesis: “This one, at last, is bone of my bones and flesh of my flesh.” (Genesis 2:23)

He was fascinated with her body, but for different reasons than man today is fascinated with a woman’s body. At this point the man and the woman did not yet know sin; their vision was perfectly clear, not clouded by impure thoughts and selfish desires. They saw in each other’s naked bodies only the beauty and glory of the God who just created them, and the privilege to love each other with their bodies as God loves. The first man and woman saw in each other’s bodies the call to become one in loving and life-giving communion, to become the very image of the Holy Trinity. That is what fascinated and excited them about each other’s bodies.

The man in this original state of innocence could not be excited by another man’s body, for he would not see any way to join himself to another man in a fruitful union imaging the Holy Trinity. The woman could not be excited by the body of another woman. Man and woman were created with an innate yearning to join with each other in fruitful union, and their bodies were designed to accommodate that yearning.

After the fall into sin (where humanity no longer knew only goodness, but now evil as well) human sexuality lost its purely God-centered focus. The self-centered allure of pleasure now tempted the man and the woman, competing with the true meaning of their sexuality--and it often won. The excitement of genital activity shifted from the God-centered participation in divine love to the self-centered lust for pleasure; once that shift was made humanity fell into its ultimate trap, which is spelled out simply as follows:

When we seek only God we are satisfied, for only God can fulfill our needs. When we seek things other than God we are never satisfied, so we search for fulfillment in novel ways that temporarily please us but never really satisfy.

That’s what happened when humanity lost the true focus of sexuality. Having lost sight of its divine purpose men and women began to experiment, employing other parts of each other’s bodies in search of sexual fulfillment, parts that were not designed to be employed in this manner. Men also began to experiment with men, and women with women. They even began experimenting with their own bodies, finding ways to stimulate themselves without a partner, becoming totally self-absorbed in their own pleasure and eliminating the unitive and procreative purpose.

None of this ultimately satisfies, because none of it is of God. And yet fallen man continues to explore these futile avenues, no matter how many times they result in a dead-end.

In the context of the question at hand, when it comes to all of these un-Godly sexual feelings and practices we need to ask: are homosexuals at least in the same boat as heterosexuals in falling short of the plan for sexuality?

Think about it: a heterosexual person who has entertained fantasies about or engaged in genital activity involving non-sexual body parts, or who has given themselves sexual pleasure in solitude, or who has engaged in natural genital union outside the marriage covenant, or in the marriage covenant while sterilizing its procreative function, or when driven by the primary motive of self-seeking pleasure rather than the self-donation of Godly love, really doesn’t have a stone to throw at anyone. All of these sexual thoughts and behaviors--whether one is predominantly heterosexual or homosexual in orientation--have the same root cause. We all came from the same place.

Does that not place us in the same boat? (The image of a boat is used here not coincidentally, by the way, since it is a prime image of the Church.)

Some would argue no. There is a fundamental difference that seems to be the crux of the matter, that makes many people mistakenly view the law of the body as discriminatory to those with a same-sex attraction: heterosexuals have the opportunity to express the true nuptial meaning of the body (the image of God’s self-donating, fruitful and covenantal love with another) but homosexuals do not. Doesn’t justice dictate they also be allowed to have a dedicated partner to love?

But the question is based on the fallacy that homosexuals do not have the opportunity to express the true nuptial meaning of the body, the expression that God intends for every human body. But the fact is they do, and they can express the true nuptial meaning of the body in a powerful way that many heterosexuals do.


St. John Paul II taught that emphatically in his Theology of the Body. We’ll explore that topic in my next post.

Monday, November 10, 2014

Welcoming Homosexuals in the Church: The Real Question

For centuries the Church has gone forth to all nations seeking the lost. But what about the lost we don’t need to go forth to seek--those who show up at our door?

This is the question regarding homosexual persons raised at the recent Extraordinary Synod of Bishops on the Family:

“Homosexuals have gifts and qualities to offer to the Christian community; are we capable of welcoming these people, guaranteeing to them a fraternal space in our communities? Often they wish to encounter a Church that offers them a welcoming home. Are our communities capable of providing that, accepting and valuing their sexual orientation without compromising Catholic doctrine on the family and matrimony?”

This paragraph from the mid-term report raised a lot of eyebrows. One of the flash fires it ignited was seemingly extinguished when it was noted that “valuing their sexual orientation” was a mistranslation; the Italian word rendered in English as “valuing” actually means “evaluating.”

But the question it raised--yes, raised, not yet answered--is one the Church needs to address:

“Are we capable of welcoming these people, guaranteeing to them a fraternal space in our communities….without compromising Catholic doctrine on the family and matrimony?”

First we need to listen to what the question is asking. When examined in the broader context of the Synod’s other documents, its true meaning emerges: do we open our doors not only to repentant sinners, but to those not aware of the sinfulness of their ways?

The preparatory document issued in June of 2014, based on responses to a survey of the word’s episcopal conferences, made this prescient point:

“Some episcopal conferences argue that the reason for much resistance to the Church’s teaching on moral issues related to the family is a want of an authentic Christian experience, namely, an encounter with Christ on a personal and communal level, for which no doctrinal presentation, no matter how accurate, can substitute. In this regard, some responses point to the insufficiency of pastoral activity which is concerned only with dispensing the sacraments, without a truly engaging Christian experience.”

In other words, we can teach doctrine until we’re blue in the face; but if someone has not truly experienced Jesus Christ--at both a personal level and within the community of believers--as well as the change of heart that comes with an authentic experience of Christ, then even the clearest doctrinal teaching won’t accomplish anything.

How does this apply to the question at hand? Consider the following.

Every human person needs Jesus Christ, for all have fallen short of the glory of God. Homosexual persons, especially those in sexually active relationships, need Jesus Christ--and here’s a key point--whether they realize it or not.

(St. Augustine once said, quite admirably: “I shall seek the lost. Whether they wish it or not, I shall do it.” Once again, if the Church seeks the lost in far-away lands whether they wish it or not, what are we to do with the lost who show up at our door, whether they wish to be considered lost or not?)

How will such persons get to know Jesus Christ, or even come to the realization that they need him, if the Christian community, the very body of Christ, shuns them by barring them from their company?

We hold as infallible truth that genuine repentance is necessary for forgiveness of sin. Yes, the unrepentant sinner is not forgiven. But here’s the pastoral challenge: we often speak of keeping the doors of the Church open for repentant sinners, but do we hold the doors open for the unrepentant as well, in the hope they will discover within these doors their need to repent?

The question raised at the Synod is not should the Church give her blessing to homosexual relationships, for the answer is clearly no. The question is not should persons in homosexual relationships be admitted to the Eucharist, for the answer is clearly no. The question is not should a homosexual lifestyle be valued as a good in our communities, for the answer is clearly no.

The question is: “Are we capable of welcoming these people, guaranteeing to them a fraternal space in our communities….without compromising Catholic doctrine on the family and matrimony?”

How can someone repent of sin if they don’t know the truth? As Paul asked the Church in Rome: How can they call on him in whom they have not believed? And how can they believe in him of whom they have not heard? (Romans 10:14) Believing in Jesus means more than being the subject of catechesis--it means having one’s heart touched and changed by him. How can anyone’s heart be touched and changed by Jesus unless his Body is willing to welcome them in their company?

What is being asked is this: is there a place in our communities for those who aren’t aware of the serious implications of their lifestyle, to offer them the possibility of “an authentic Christian experience, namely, an encounter with Christ on a personal and communal level, for which no doctrinal presentation, no matter how accurate, can substitute”?

The question has been asked. Now for the work of finding an answer.


Saturday, November 8, 2014

Theology of the Body in Bite-Size Pieces, Part Nine

Think of someone you love dearly—a parent, spouse, child, relative or close friend. Imagine having no physical contact whatsoever with that person—you never experienced a hug, a kiss, a handshake, a pat on the back, an arm around a shoulder, or holding a hand. Imagine if that relationship consisted of words and spiritual presence alone, with no physical touch.

Would you be satisfied with that, or would you need something more?

Even with a strong spiritual presence, a relationship without physical touch falls short of all that it can be. (In fact, studies of infants who do not experience touch reveal many adverse effects, underscoring the basic, uncompromising need for physical contact in human relationships.)

The reason touch is so important is because we are not just spiritual beings—we are physical as well, and the body and spirit work in tandem. The spirit lives in and through the body; the body lives because of the spirit. The Catechism of the Catholic Church goes so far as to say that “spirit and matter, in man, are not two natures united, but rather their union forms a single nature.” (#365) This is why we need to connect with our loved ones not only spiritually, but especially physically.

If human-to-human relationships require physical interaction, how much more so does a human relationship with God, the ultimate source and object of our love. We sometimes think of our relationship with God as strictly spiritual. But we cannot have a complete relationship with God on a purely spiritual level—because we are not purely spiritual. A relationship with God that exists only on the spiritual plane falls far short of all that it can and should be; we need to physically touch God in order to be whole.

God knows this, and in his infinite wisdom and love he provided ways for this physical interaction to happen.

In Jesus Christ, the eternal Word made flesh, God and humanity became physically and spiritually one. The Gospels are filled with stories of people longing to touch Jesus—and Jesus longing to touch people. (A few examples are Mark 3:10, Mark 8:22, Mark 10:13, Luke 6:19, Matthew 8:2-3,, Matthew 8:14-15, Matthew 9:28-30, Matthew 17:6-7, and Matthew 20:34.) As these passages indicate, we need Jesus—God in human flesh—not just for the sake of his touch in itself. We need the healing that only Jesus’ physical and spiritual touch can bring. What we ultimately need to be healed of is sin. Since sin infects both our bodies and our souls, we need to be touched by God both physically and spiritually to receive total healing and salvation.

This is why Jesus instructed the Apostles to not just verbally teach, but to physically heal (Matthew 10:8), to baptize (Matthew 28:19), to consume his Body and Blood (John 6:53-58) and to provide his Body and Blood for others to eat and drink under the appearance of bread and wine (1 Corinthians 11:23-25) so God’s people could be both physically and spiritually one with him, in answer to Jesus’ prayer the night before he died:

“Just as you sent me into the world, I, too, have sent them into the world…. I’m praying not only for them but also for those who believe in me through their word, so that all may be one, just as you, Father, are in me and I in you, so they, too, may be in us.” (John 17: 18, 20-21)

Jesus established the Church as sacrament, a visible sign of the invisible reality of God, through which he would dispense his grace through physical touch just as he had done throughout his public ministry. This touch would be given through the sacraments Jesus entrusted to the Church, through which the spirit would be touched as well.

Tertullian, a Christian writer from the late second and early third centuries, wrote about the spirit’s dependence upon the nourishment of the sacraments received through the body:


“No soul can ever obtain salvation unless while it is in the flesh it has become a believer. To such a degree is the flesh the pivot of salvation, that since by it the soul becomes linked with God, it is the flesh which makes possible the soul’s election by God. For example, the flesh is washed that the soul may be made spotless; the flesh is anointed that the soul may be consecrated; the flesh is signed (with the cross) that the soul too may be protected; the flesh is overshadowed by the imposition of the hand that the soul may be illumined by the Spirit; the flesh feeds on the Body and Blood of Christ so that the soul also may be replete with God.”

Friday, November 7, 2014

Getting God in the Game

"Getting God in the Game: Living Faith Through Sports" is another blog of mine. You can check it out by clicking here.

Theology of the Body in Bite-Size Pieces, Part Eight

As a seque from what we’ve established so far and where we’re going next, I’d like to share this excerpt from my novel “Mowgli and the Missionary.” Death was introduced into the human condition through sin, in which we sever our connection to our source of life. Our life is restored through Jesus Christ, who took on human flesh so it could be sacrificed for our sins. This all has a very physical, bodily component, as this passage explains.

Here Brother Jude, the missionary, has just led Mowgli through a contemplative exercise in which he imagines his human parents whom he lost as a toddler holding him.

“That’s something like how I speak with Jesus,” said Jude.
“But they really weren’t here,” said Mowgli, continuing to wipe away tears. “I only talked to them in my imagination. You can imagine Jesus anywhere too. How can you say you miss him? At least my parents once held me; Jesus has never touched you.”
As his heart rose within him Jude’s hands reached once again for Mowgli’s shoulders, and his eyes stared deeply into his. “Yes he has. Jesus has touched me so many times, Mowgli, in ways I can’t find here, and I miss that very much.”
Mowgli’s smile was not so much of amusement, or mockery, or awkward unease, but of wondrous anticipation of whatever might be coming next.
“Go ahead,” he replied, shaking his head and smiling even more broadly. “Tell me how you’ve been touched by Jesus.”
Jude invited the boy to sit with him, then took a deep breath.
“Mowgli, you’ve seen newborn animals nursed by their mothers. Everyone begins life by feeding off the body of someone else, of the one who gave them life, right?”
“Of course.”
“What is their food in those early days of life? What do they draw from their mother’s body?”
“They drink milk,” said the boy, frustrated with Jude’s fixation on the obvious.
“And that not only feeds their body, but creates a strong bond between them.”
Mowgli hung his head, and Jude hung his as well, realizing too late he had struck a sensitive spot. Mowgli saw his remorse from the corner of his eye.
“It’s okay,” said the boy, gently nodding his head. “Keep going.”
Jude sighed before continuing.
“Can this milk sustain them as they get older?”
“Of course not,” answered Mowgli. “Animals must learn to walk and to run, to build shelter and to hunt. They need other food to help them become strong.”
“You’re right,” said Jude. “And so the flesh eaters kill for their meals, or their parents kill for them until they learn to do so. And the plant eaters take living, growing things into their mouths and annihilate them, killing them to give them their nourishment.”
“Everyone knows this,” said Mowgli. “Why do you speak of this?”
“Maybe you can figure out why. There’s a difference between the milk that nourishes creatures in the early days of life, and the flesh and plants and fruits that must sustain a body when life gets more demanding. The difference has to do with what happens to the source of the food once the meal is eaten. Can you think of that difference?”
Mowgli thought for just a moment, his eyes never leaving Jude’s.
“The one who gives milk lives after the feeding, but an animal or plant must die to feed others.”
“That’s right,” said Jude, nodding emphatically. “You and I are alive today because all through our lives something else gave its life so we can have ours. Whether an animal that was hunted or a fruit or plant that was once living and growing, something else has to die so we can live, their bodies mingling with ours to nourish us. When we eat we become one with what gives its life for us.”
Mowgli had never considered that he owed such a debt to so many, more than just the bull that bought him.
“We don’t usually feel the same bond with them as we do with our mothers, but we should, because a bond is certainly there.”
“You’re right,” said Mowgli. “I’ve never thought of that before. But what does this has to do with Jesus?”
Jude spotted a rotting mango lying on the ground and retrieved it.
“Can you see how this mango is now dead, and why?” asked Jude.
“Of course,” said Mowgli, “it’s rotting because it fell from the tree.”
“The tree gave birth to it and nourished it, and as long as it remained attached to the tree it lived.”
“Of course,” said Mowgli.
“Now it has died, because it’s separated from what gave it life and sustained it. Can it restore itself to life?”
“No, it can’t re-attach itself to the tree.”
“Of course not. And that’s how we are when we separate from God. Like a rotting mango no longer on the tree, apart from what sustains its life, so are we because we separated from God by turning to other things. The food of this earth now only keeps us alive for so long. So God became human in Jesus so he could also die, and through his death he would become the food that keeps us alive forever.”
“But Jesus is a man,” protested Mowgli. “Men don’t eat other men. That’s not right.”
“Jesus changes bread and wine into his body and blood, so he can feed us and become one with us by what still seems to be regular food. That’s how Jesus touches me and holds me, and this is what I miss so terribly.”

Read the first two chapters of "Mowgli and the Missionary" by clicking here.


Thursday, November 6, 2014

Theology of the Body in Bite-Size Pieces, Part Seven

The woman saw that the tree was good for food, pleasing to the eyes, and desirable for gaining wisdom. So she took some of its fruit and ate it; and she also gave some to her husband, who was with her, and he ate it. Then the eyes of both of them were opened, and they realized that they were naked; so they sewed fig leaves together and made loincloths for themselves.” (Genesis 3:6-7)

As we noted in Part Four, the man and woman before the fall were naked without shame:

“At this point the man and woman do not know sin; their vision is perfectly clear, not clouded by sinful inclinations and selfish desires. They see in each other’s bodies nothing but the beauty and glory of God--and the incredible privilege they have been granted to love each other with their bodies as God loves.

“That’s the fascination, that’s the excitement. They see in their genitals the gift to be joined as one body in a life-giving union--an image of the Holy Trinity--and this fascinates and excites them.”

They knew only the goodness of their sexuality.

But now they have eaten of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil!
They know evil for the first time, and it repulses them. They now see in their bodies something else--the ability to grasp at each other as a possession and not as a gift, to use each other for selfish purposes, to look upon each other as objects instead of subjects, to use their genitals in ways they were not made to be used--and they are frightened. They cover up in fear as well as shame, for they now feel threatened by the other’s ability to use them rather than love them.

As an analogy, imagine someone who does not do well with horror movies discovering one on television late at night. They know they shouldn’t look, but can’t resist the temptation. “I’ll just watch for a minute”--and then quickly they see things they would rather not have seen. Now instead of sleeping peacefully they’ll have nightmares because of what they saw.

This is similar to what happened to the man and the woman in Genesis 3:6-7. God had warned them about this tree, and about knowledge that belongs to him alone. He knew there were things the man and the woman would rather not see--that they shouldn’t see--things so far outside the bounds of purity and holiness that it would affect the way they think and act.

They also discovered there was some truth to the serpent’s statement, and consequences they did not take into consideration: “God knows well that the moment you eat of it your eyes will be opened and you will be like gods who know what is good and what is bad.” Yes, they will be “like gods,” and in becoming their own gods they will separate themselves from the true God, the source and sustainer of their life--and thus they will die. They are now doomed to struggle with evil and eventually succumb to death as a consequence of their disobedience.

As we noted in Part Three, God does not say “the moment you eat from it I will kill you.” God says “the moment you eat from it you are surely doomed to die.” Death is a natural consequence of separating yourself from your source of life. The man and woman have brought this upon themselves.

Now they see in their bodies things they were not originally made for--selfish, lustful thoughts and desires, and a slow process of corruption that will ultimately lead to death.


We’ll contemplate in a bit more depth these implications in Part Eight, before moving on to God’s plan to save them from this mess in Part Nine.